September Farm

David and Roberta Rotelle
460 Mill Road
Honey Brook, PA 19344

Phone: 610.273.3552
Web site:
Shop hours: Mon.–Sat., 9 a.m. – 5 p.m.

Located in Honey Brook, Chester County, Pa., September Farm is owned and operated by David and Roberta Rotelle. The couple and their family make cheese using fresh, pasteurized, hormone-free milk from Holstein cows raised on their award-winning dairy farm. Their cheeses are made on September Farm, free from preservatives with the finest all-natural ingredients following time-proven traditions for the hand crafting, hand waxing, and aging of artisan-style cheeses.

September Farm controls every aspect of cheese making. They raise their dairy herd on forages grown at September Farm, and hours-old milk goes directly from milking to the cheese vat to the aging room and then hand waxed. The forages that feed September Farm cows grow upon some of the richest soils in the area, and the Honey Brook waters used to make the cheese gets its name from town’s high water quality. From fields to cows, from the milk to the cheese vat, the Rotelle family’s personal commitment to producing the highest quality dairy products shows.

September Farm is recognized as a Dairy of Distinction by the Northeast Dairy Farm Beautification Program. Dave and Roberta are licensed cheese makers from the University of Wisconsin and are also members of the American Cheese Society. In addition, Dave represents the fourth generation of his family to serve the food industry.

September Farm invites the public to watch the cheese being made, and presentations on the cheese-making process can be arranged for small groups. All September Farm Cheese, including their monthly featured flavor, can be purchased at their farm’s shop, from the farm’s Web site, by phone or e-mail.  September Farm Cheese can also be found at any one of the listed retail locations; at select farmers markets in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware and Maryland; and can be shipped anywhere.

Our Cheese Varieties

Cheese Curds

Bite size pieces of fresh cheddar before aging; offers a squeaky, fresh and salty taste. Available in three flavors: Tomato Basil, Roasted Garlic, and Cajun. Visit September Farm at 4:30 p.m. on cheese making days to get curds warm, right out of the vat.


Homemade Cheese Balls

Made fresh weekly by hand using sharp and extra-sharp cheddar and rolled in pecans and parsley. Flavors include: Garlic Herb, Cranberry Honey, Smokey Bacon, and Horseradish.


Honey Brook Mild Cheddar
Creamy mild cheddar flavor; aged three months.


Honey Brook Medium Cheddar
Aged six months.


Honey Brook Sharp
Aged one year.


Honey Brook Extra Sharp Cheddar
Distinctively sharp; aged over one year.


Honey Brook Smoked Cheddar
Savory smoky flavor.


Honey Brook Bacon Smoked Cheddar
September Farm’s popular smoked cheddar with bacon added


Honey Brook Horse Radish Cheddar
Made with freshly prepared horse radish.


Honey Brook Chili Pepper Cheddar
Made with chili peppers and seeds; September Farm’s hottest cheese.


Honey Brook Muffalletta Cheddar
Made with a blend of olives and garlic.


Jumpin’ Jack Jalapeno
Fresh and creamy Monterey Jack cheese made with jalapenos.


Honey Jack
A mild Monterey Jack cheese with a touch of honey.


Pepperoni Augusto Jack
A Monterey Jack cheese that tastes like pizza; made with pepperoni, garlic and oregano and then rolled in special seasonings before packaging.


Chives & Dill Jack
September Farm’s award-winning cheese, having earned the 2009 American Cheese Society Award, Second Place. A Monterey Jack cheese with a fresh taste of chives and rolled in dill before packaging.


Garlic and Basil Jack
A Monterey Jack cheese made with garlic and basil to offer Italian flavors.


Joy’s Tomato Basil Jack
Sun-dried tomatoes and basil give this Monterey Jack cheese its flavor.

Apple Cinimon Cheddar

Award winning cheddar with apples, dusted in cinnamon. Perfect for the Holidays!


Authentic Amish Cup Cheese 

Retail Locations

On Farm

September Farm
460 Mill Road
Honey Brook, Pa. 19344

Farmers Markets/Farm Stands

Dutch Country Farmers Market
Middleton, Del.




September Farm Store
Prime Retail Outlet
460 Mill Road
Honey Brook, PA 19344

Beavertown Grocery
Middleburg, Pa.

Blair Vineyards
Kutztown, Pa.

Bolton Farm Market
Silverdale, Pa.

Country Store
3140 Mount Joy Road
Mount Joy, Pa. 17552 

Dutchway Farm Market
Myerstown and Schaefferstown, Pa.  

Farmers’ Daughter Farm Market
Spring City, Pa. 

Frecon Farms
Boyertown, Pa.  

Freddy Hill Farms
Lansdale, Pa. 

Hennings Market
Harleysville, Pa. 

Hershey’s Farm Market
Parkesburg, Pa. 

Hunters Valley Winery
Liverpool, Pa. 

Kolb’s Farm Store
Spring City, Pa. 

Kreutz Creek Vineyards
West Grove & West Chester, Pa.

Landis Supermarket
Perkasie, Schwenksville, Vernfield and Telford, Pa. locations 

Lansdale Meats & Deli Colonial Village
Lansdale, Pa. 

Longview Center Market
Collegeville, Pa. 

Manatawny Creek Winery
Douglassville, Pa.

Manoff Market Gardens
Solebury, Pa.

Martin’s Trailside Express
East Earl, Pa. 

Merrymead Farm & Country Market
Lansdale, Pa. 

Old Dutch Cupboard
Moyer Road & Route 113
Franconia, Pa.

Oregon Dairy
Lancaster, Pa. 

Paradocx Vineyard
Kennett Square, Pa. 

Perrydell Farm Dairy
York, Pa. 

R & J Farm Market
Souderton, Pa. 

Shady Maple Farmers Market
East Earl, Pa.

Stoltzfus Market Market
3801 Horseshoe Pike
Honey Brook, PA 19344

Suloman’s Dairy
Gilbertsville, Pa. 

Tabora Farm & Orchard
Chalfont, Pa. 

Town Clock Cheese Shoppe
5381 Bridge St, Gap, PA 17527
Wed.–Sat., 10 a.m.-6 p.m.

Traugers Farm Market 
Kintnersville, Pa. 

Treasures of Oley
Oley, Pa. 

Weaver Markets
Adamstown, Pa. 

Weaver’s Orchard
Morgantown, Pa. 

Weiser’s Market
Akron and Lititz, Pa. 

W.L. Zimmerman & Son
Intercourse, Pa. 

Yoder’s Country Market
New Holland, Pa. 

Zig’s Bakery and Deli
Lititz, PA 17543